Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post pics of your car in here
Post Reply
Abarthnorway - Remi L
Posts: 207
Joined: June 24th, 2006, 1:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Abarthnorway - Remi L »

Hi!


As far as one can get from italian machinery - but in a way fascinating in its own way.

This is the first model of the SL Pagode series - 4 speed box - no aircon - and a small capacity inline 6. Not big in power but high in comfort. This engine has 2300 cc, 150 hp and mechanical Bosch injection. Interesting fact is that it has an air density valve on the fuelline that control the fuel pressure, so the mixture will always be correct even when driving at high altitude.... 1965! Revvhappy engine - needs 4000 and up to really get going - redline approx 6500. Car glides ahead like a dream in 150km/h even when the top is down.


The car is now ready for build, and the whole project feels like a neverendig process. This was high tech in 1965 - still complicated today.
Current status - ready for build. Now absolutely 100% rust free - was a true basket case in 2005.
Current status - ready for build. Now absolutely 100% rust free - was a true basket case in 2005.
HPIM1272_edited.jpg (64.38 KiB) Viewed 12138 times

To the more interesting part - cylinder head - now 47 Years old:
Cylinderhead compared to a Fiat 8VTC
Cylinderhead compared to a Fiat 8VTC
DSC_3205.jpg (190.6 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Intake/exhaust side - see the threaded hole over the inlet ports - its for the injectors.
Intake/exhaust side - see the threaded hole over the inlet ports - its for the injectors.
DSC_3206.jpg (196.06 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Spark plug side
Spark plug side
DSC_3208.jpg (173.9 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Spark plug side
Spark plug side
DSC_3209.jpg (209.04 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Head face
Head face
DSC_3210.jpg (190.57 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Combustion chamber
Combustion chamber
DSC_3211.jpg (161.97 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Inlet valve 39 mm 9 stem - a "wall" of 2 mm surrounds the valve - 45`valve seats
Inlet valve 39 mm 9 stem - a "wall" of 2 mm surrounds the valve - 45`valve seats
DSC_3212.jpg (108.86 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Exhaust valves sodium cooled 35 mm 11 stem - 45`valve seats I think
Exhaust valves sodium cooled 35 mm 11 stem - 45`valve seats I think
DSC_3213.jpg (128.74 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Valve/ Cam/ Springs/ Rockers etc - SOHC ala Mercedes 65 - approx 10 mm valve lift
Valve/ Cam/ Springs/ Rockers etc - SOHC ala Mercedes 65 - approx 10 mm valve lift
DSC_3214.jpg (173.69 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Manifold stud 1
Manifold stud 1
DSC_3216.jpg (157.18 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Manifold stud 2
Manifold stud 2
DSC_3217.jpg (187 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Inlet port approx 34*36 bronce guides
Inlet port approx 34*36 bronce guides
DSC_3218.jpg (90.17 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Broken stud 3
Broken stud 3
DSC_3219.jpg (174.45 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
Exhaust port rectangular - bronce valve guides
Exhaust port rectangular - bronce valve guides
DSC_3220.jpg (57.48 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
corrosion
corrosion
DSC_3221.jpg (140.26 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
coolant passage corrosion plug side
coolant passage corrosion plug side
DSC_3222.jpg (149.71 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
coolant passage corrosion plug side
coolant passage corrosion plug side
DSC_3223.jpg (171.27 KiB) Viewed 12138 times
coolant passage corrosion port side - lead inserts completely rotten
coolant passage corrosion port side - lead inserts completely rotten
DSC_3225.jpg (165.77 KiB) Viewed 12138 times

This head need some good care - hopefully it will be fit for duty without the biggest repairs....
47 Year takes its toll on any engine, but at least this head seems to have the correct thickness - that means it has not been refaced a lot of times.
Fingers crossed.

Best regards

Remi Lovhoiden
Last edited by Abarthnorway - Remi L on March 7th, 2012, 10:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
GC_45
Menios
Posts: 3
Joined: July 28th, 2011, 9:29 am

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Menios »

Nice project there.
I will watch this space.
What are your plans with the engine and head?
Just repair or a touch up to improve driveability?
Abarthnorway - Remi L
Posts: 207
Joined: June 24th, 2006, 1:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Abarthnorway - Remi L »

Menios wrote:Nice project there.
I will watch this space.
What are your plans with the engine and head?
Just repair or a touch up to improve driveability?
Hi Menios!


This car has been a constant headache since day 1, but my stubborness has prevented me from a cut and run.
All mistakes are a possibility to learn something....

The car was bought in 2004 with engine issues. I took cylinderhead and other pieces off because it ran very badly, and some major issues were adressed at that point. A very quick rebuild of the head followed. Most serious thing though was that the crank front pulley was 180 degrees off - and the engine almost jumped off its engine mounts when I got it - the pulley acts as some kind of weight on the crank and when fitted the wrong way the whole car shook violently. The car had been to several mercedes experts without finding the actual problem.... I sometimes do not understand how skilled and educated people can miss a thing like that. Too simple and obvious maybe. The good thing was that the ignition, injectors and lots of bits got changed during faultfinding. But spring 2005 it didn`t want to cooperate with me anymore, and I ripped the engine out and I have done nothing to it except dismantling.

Secondly I knew the bodywork needed some "small work" - under the cosmetic coverup and freshly painted shell - a body restoration was planned.
Here is how that ended:
Well this is how far it went - almost all outer panels and parts of the frame now renewed.....
Well this is how far it went - almost all outer panels and parts of the frame now renewed.....
220SL(~1.JPG (520.42 KiB) Viewed 12084 times
And after some more work:
Proper rust proofing
Proper rust proofing
DSC_0778.JPG (83.96 KiB) Viewed 12084 times
DSC08539.JPG
DSC08539.JPG (81.96 KiB) Viewed 12084 times
Nut & Bolt restore
Nut & Bolt restore
DSC_0862.JPG (98.41 KiB) Viewed 12084 times
Done
Done
DSC_1233.JPG (60.93 KiB) Viewed 12084 times


Now:
HPIM1270.jpg
HPIM1270.jpg (94.95 KiB) Viewed 12084 times

I would like the engine to be as good as the outside, and my expert body restorer is not neccesarily a good engine builder I have concluded! The consequence is that this head will be sent to GC for inspection - and most possibly an overhaul. I am not looking for power tuning, but making the best of the original setup without sacrificing too much originality - same same but different. So if You want an updates on the head - better ask him.... I am just crossing my fingers that the head will survive his critical analysis, without too many nasty sceletons falling out of the closet. I know already know that a lot of things needs to be done.

The block or crankcase I will probably build myself, and machining will be done by a reputable engine shop that is not the cheapest around. But excellent value for money....
Parts are expensive and a bit of a problem sometimes for the 1. series engine. I just cannot find piston rings to suit the pistons and they have weird sizes - the thickest approx 4mm thick. If I can source rings new liners will be fitted. An alternative is to fit new original oversize pistons, but they are so expensive that custom made forged ones are tempting. Haven`t come so far as to decide on it yet.

Regarding the injection system I am a novice - and anyone with experience of the Bosch mechanical injection pump fitted to the Pagoda feel free to share their knowledge. I am reading up on this pump at the moment, and it seems to be rather advanced like everything else on this car.

All in all I am a bit frightened of this car as it is very overengineered in most ways. Very complex and refined, and as I am used to the simpler but brilliant Fiat mechanicals I feel a bit overwhelmed at times.

This is a long term project, and will probably take another couple of years to complete - I will keep You posted.


Remi
GC_45
samo
Posts: 222
Joined: December 6th, 2010, 6:52 am

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by samo »

Hi Remi,

I am not a big fan of german cars, despite the fact the egineering is just fascinating but I am a fan of good restoration projects. Brilliant work! If you have any more pics of the before and after of the parts and body please publish them.

Best of luck, Samo
Limited edition #317
TomLouwrier
Posts: 333
Joined: July 28th, 2010, 3:09 pm
Location: Leiden, The Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by TomLouwrier »

Oh dear Lord! What a job!
Yes, Mercs are complex high end machines today, and they were so back then too. I've seen some of these going through restoration and Hats Off To You for going this far with it. In the end you will certainly have a very beautiful and valuable car. That is; if you're actually counting money and hours on this one.

Looking at your head (well... your car's head I mean) there's quite some corrosion damage in the casting, the valves and the cam shaft. Hopefully you'll be able to save it. Personally I would absolutely try and do some work on the ports and chambers. Not to make a full racing machine out of it, but 'optimizing' is always good. That valve shrouding just can't be the best way.

Keep us posted, please!

regards
Tom
GC_29
Abarthnorway - Remi L
Posts: 207
Joined: June 24th, 2006, 1:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Abarthnorway - Remi L »

TomLouwrier wrote:Oh dear Lord! What a job!
Yes, Mercs are complex high end machines today, and they were so back then too. I've seen some of these going through restoration and Hats Off To You for going this far with it. In the end you will certainly have a very beautiful and valuable car. That is; if you're actually counting money and hours on this one.

Looking at your head (well... your car's head I mean) there's quite some corrosion damage in the casting, the valves and the cam shaft. Hopefully you'll be able to save it. Personally I would absolutely try and do some work on the ports and chambers. Not to make a full racing machine out of it, but 'optimizing' is always good. That valve shrouding just can't be the best way.

Keep us posted, please!

regards
Tom
Yes its been a tough project - I will never again even consider to start anything like this..... learning the hard way. Never count money or hours when restoring a car.......
It is a car with a certain value and charisma, and even though You can still find them in huge numbers - the really good ones are far between.

Regarding the head (and rest of the engine) there is lots and lots of work to be done, but considering its age of 47 years what can You expect? The corrosion is what worries me most - on the cam its only superficial, will have to see how deep the rot goes in the channels. Hopefully the ww2 tank robustness will save it. It really is solid piece of work!!
I do not understand why You mentioned inlet valve shrouding!?;-)......

Buying or sourcing another head is an option I consider - GC will have to inspect, and I will make my desicions from that report. The head will most probably be kept close to standard with only subtle modifications - Its going on the road, and originality has a certain value in these cars.

Will keep You posted.
samo wrote:Hi Remi,

I am not a big fan of german cars, despite the fact the egineering is just fascinating but I am a fan of good restoration projects. Brilliant work! If you have any more pics of the before and after of the parts and body please publish them.

Best of luck, Samo
No I am not the biggest fan either, never will be - but its a seriosly comfortable and pleasant experience to drive especially with the top ON. The issue here is that I am not the only person in my family. This is a nice wife car.... and gives me an excellent excuse to spend time and money on my italian hobbies:-)
Joking aside - will post some pictures in a while - I have thousands.


Best regards

Remi
GC_45
Nobby
Posts: 87
Joined: August 24th, 2010, 11:58 am
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Nobby »

Really nice project you've got there.

The 230sl was one of the cars that really initiated my love of cars. Back when I was doing my A levels one of my Design Tech teachers wafted into the car park in a red 230sl convertible that he had just bought. It was only then that he mentioned to me that teaching was only his day job, and his real passion was restoring cars (and old bikes).

The next day he turned up in a E-type Jag! You always remember your favourite teachers.
Chris Burgess
GC 01
Menios
Posts: 3
Joined: July 28th, 2011, 9:29 am

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Menios »

Hi Remi,

Mercedes cars are not easy to play with, and everyone will go through some difficulties first.
But when the end result leaves you with a smile you forget all the pain you went through.
Being a mercedes owner myself (from another era but still old though) I can feel the confusion and sometimes the frustration.
All I can say is that you are in a point of no return and I see this work being complete soon. You have done the most difficult part which is the bodywork and it looks pretty.

Engine wise I know the trouble of finding aftermarket or replacement parts for mercedes engines.
Keeping the car original is the main constrain, but everything is possible.

My advice for the engine is as follows because the engine is quite old and it would be more economical to detect failed parts before rebuilding the engine.
1. Chemical bath the engine block and all internals (If you can have the block under X-rays it will be ideal for porosity issues and crack detection).
2. Crack detection on the cylinder head (porisity can be repaired and a port clean up from casting marks can improve driveability of the car).
3. If block requires over-boring go for it but if you can do with honning the cylinders only that should be OK. with some new piston rings (I believe that your engine block has no liners and wear shouldnot be that bad on cylinders).




All I can say is Keep Up the good work. It will be worth the pain.

Regards
Menios
WhizzMan
Posts: 459
Joined: August 13th, 2010, 8:05 pm
Location: Amsterdam, the Netherlands

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by WhizzMan »

I love to see pagodas in good condition. It looks as if you're well on the road to get yours just tip top.

I'm very interested in seeing how this head will be restored, if that is going to happen. A lot of the corrosion damage on this head is not uncommon for aluminum heads in general and getting an idea on how to judge what repair to choose and how to perform it will be most educative.
Book #348
Abarthnorway - Remi L
Posts: 207
Joined: June 24th, 2006, 1:39 pm
Location: Oslo, Norway
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Abarthnorway - Remi L »

Head is now at GC for proper treatment.

Have seen too much of bad engine overhauls - not this time, not with this car.

Remi
GC_45
Guy Croft
Site Admin
Posts: 5039
Joined: June 18th, 2006, 9:31 am
Location: Bedford, UK
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Guy Croft »

in progress at GCRE, indeed.


A bit slower than usual I'll admit but Remi has kindly indicated that this whole project will be ongoing for a fair time yet..

As the head stands at the moment we have done two weld ops and it has failed pressure test twice, the crack is deeper than I reckoned. Initially I thought the second infill had done the trick and we'd only need one new seat insert but we tried pressure test at higher pressure than normal and it just started to 'fizzle'. Now it will have to be chased out all over and deeper too. The shop that does the pressure-testing for us has their own in-house welder who is very, very good so we are just waiting for a 'slot' on that one.

G
Attachments
crack testing by NDT method (dye penetrant) and expecting a crack or 2
crack testing by NDT method (dye penetrant) and expecting a crack or 2
Remi Merc_ crack testing.JPG (172.64 KiB) Viewed 11696 times
one culprit exposed - right across the land between two valves. Highly unusual to see a 'land' right across the cylinder like this.
one culprit exposed - right across the land between two valves. Highly unusual to see a 'land' right across the cylinder like this.
Remi Merc_ crack testing (7).JPG (86.98 KiB) Viewed 11696 times
first attempt at weld infill after digging-out the crack to where I thought it finished
first attempt at weld infill after digging-out the crack to where I thought it finished
RV Merc_weld infill as at 23 Mar.JPG (124.28 KiB) Viewed 11696 times
1st weld failed pressure-test so I tried again
1st weld failed pressure-test so I tried again
RV Merc_reweld & chase out after pressure test fail (4).JPG (88.79 KiB) Viewed 11696 times
chasing-out the weld infill after second attempt at infill, dressing to an extent in fond expectation that it will pass pressure-test this time.... it did not...
chasing-out the weld infill after second attempt at infill, dressing to an extent in fond expectation that it will pass pressure-test this time.... it did not...
RV Merc_reweld & chase out after pressure test fail (1).JPG (160.7 KiB) Viewed 11696 times
Guy Croft, owner
Rallyroller
Posts: 89
Joined: May 31st, 2011, 2:40 pm
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Rallyroller »

Could the welds be porous? Impregnating porosity would cure the porosity, but not a crack.
GC_13
parrish
Posts: 62
Joined: June 22nd, 2006, 7:11 pm
Location: Teesside UK
Contact:

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by parrish »

Nice bit of penetrant testing their Guy,
Good photographs of the crack, Their are formula somewhere that allow you to calculate the volume of the crack using the time/area spread of the penetrant coming from the defect, no so sure that would tell you the depth of the crack though!
I trust you will be carrying out Penetrant inspection again after repair.
The head being relatively thin looks suitable for X-Ray (not Gamma) aliminium is a good subject and cracks and porosity always show up reasonably well, film should be placed closest to the suspect area so that would be valve side, their may be more going on under the original crack.
Sometimes people are put off by X-Ray because they think its going to cost too much, not at all, find a local NDT company and give them a call i think you will find rates reasonable.
Regards
Steve
Parrish 366
WhizzMan
Posts: 459
Joined: August 13th, 2010, 8:05 pm
Location: Amsterdam, the Netherlands

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by WhizzMan »

I was wondering why so much effort was being put in restoring a head, but then I found out what an unrestored "as is" head costs. The "as is" means no warranty, so it could just as well have cracks as this one. I hope you guys get it fixed and we get to see a lot more pictures of the restoration and preparation.
Book #348
Daveyboy
Posts: 38
Joined: March 24th, 2010, 9:21 pm
Location: Southampton

Re: Mercedes Pagoda 230 SL - 1965

Post by Daveyboy »

I feel your pain Guy, chasing out deep, old cracks in an ally casting and rewelding can be hugely frustrating. Aluminium castings can be horribly porous at the best of times, introduce a crack for oil/corrosion to get into and welding it becomes a very difficult task as any impurities trapped in a small pore or crack residue will give off vapours that ruin the gas shield and contaminate the weld pool, nasty.
GC Book # 103
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 43 guests